Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden Menu
Food - Share (Online)
Black Bean Hummus
w/ fresh vegetables & croustinis
US$10.00
Cauliflower Bites
seasoned crispy cauliflower, sweet chili sauce, w/ house ranch
US$12.00
Chicken Wings
jerk, soy & honey, or house mango habanero hot sauce
US$16.00
Fried Mozzarella
house breaded wedge w/ greens & marinara
US$10.00
Meatballs
beef & pork balls, marinara, parmesan, toasted ciabatta
US$14.00
Pork Belly
cubed & fried w/ house mango habanero hot sauce
US$12.00
Reuben Egg Rolls
slow cooked corn beef, sauerkraut, swiss, caraway, w/ thousand island dressing
US$14.00
Shoestring Fries
seasoned & served w/ garlic herb aioli
US$8.00
Tuna Poke
tropical fruit, sesame, habanero, red & green onions, w/ greens & yuca chips
US$17.00
Food - Start
Gazpacho
chilled tomato & cucumber soup w/ sour cream & herb oil
US$8.00
Scotch Eggs
boiled egg, spiced pork sausage, breadcrumbs, w/ mustard sauce, pickled mustard seeds
US$14.00
Food - Flatbreads (Online)
Cheese Flatbread
marinara, mozzarella
US$10.00
Pig N' Pickle Flatbread
spiced ground pork, pickles, seeded mustard bbq sauce, mozzarella
US$17.00
Shrimp Scampi Flatbread
shrimp, roasted garlic puree, tomato, mozzarella, pepperjack, lemon zest
US$19.00
Summer Garden Flatbread
marinara, spinach, tomatoes, zucchini, mozzarella, parmesan
US$16.00
Food - Greens
Burrata Salad
mixed greens, tomato, basil pesto, burrata cheese,balsamic reduction, extra virgin olive oil
US$14.00
Grilled Greek Salad
grilled romaine, feta, red onion, kalamata olives, cucumber, tomato, citrus vinaigrette
US$12.00
Mixed Greens
tomato, cucumber, red onions, red cabbage, carrots, citrus vinaigrette
US$10.00
Superfood Salad
mixed greens, quinoa, beets, almonds, citrus, sprouts, orangebeet vinaigrette
US$12.00
Tavern Wedge
iceburg, tomato, bacon, red onion, blue cheese, house blue cheese dressing
US$10.00
Food - Add Ons
Blackened Cauliflower Florets
US$5.00
Blackened Grouper
US$12.00
Grilled Shrimp
US$9.00
Marinated Chicken Breast
US$7.00
Food - Pub Favorites
Bangers & Mash
irish pork bangers mashed potatoes, sage onion gravy
US$21.00
Fish & Chips
smithwicks ale battered grouper,hand cut fries, tartar
US$24.00
Glazed Chicken Stir-Fry
mango habanero glazed chicken breast served over an asian style quinoa stir-fry w/ cabbage,cauliflower, carrots, mushrooms, peppers,ginger, garlic,soy, citrus
US$29.00
Marinated Rib Eye
grilled 12oz steak, mashed potatoes, brandy green peppercorn cream sauce
US$36.00
Shepherds Pie
ground beef & lamb stew,mashed potatoes, parmesan
US$20.00
Shrimp Linguine
basil & tomato cream sauce, mushrooms, spinach,parmesan
US$29.00
Food - Hands
Blackened Cauliflower Wrap
blackened florets, black bean hummus, red cabbage, tomatoes, sprouts, red pepper, citrus vinaigrette
US$17.00
Chipotle Chicken Sandwich
marinated & grilled chicken breast, chipotle aioli, smoked gouda, lettuce, tomato, brioche bun
US$17.00
Vegetable Banh Mi
braised napa cabbage, mushroom pate, ginger miso vegan mayo, pickled carrots & daikon, cucumber, jalapeno, cilantro, artisan roll
US$17.00
Chicken Banh Mi
marinated & grilled chicken breast, pate, ginger miso mayo, pickled carrots & daikon, cucumber, jalapeno, cilantro, artisan roll
US$17.00
Pork Banh Mi
pork belly, pate, ginger miso mayo, pickled carrots & daikon, cucumber, jalapeno, cilantro, artisan roll
US$17.00
Grouper Sandwich
smithwicks ale battered grouper, remoulade, lettuce, tomato, brioche bun
US$20.00
Tavern Steak Sandwich
marinated & grilled ribeye, spicy tomato relish, mixed greens, garlic aioli, artisan roll
US$19.00
Cheesy Pete Burger
ground angus, double cheddar, bacon, brioche bun
US$18.00
Old Town Burger
ground angus, pickles, mustard, lettuce, tomato, red onion, mayo, cheddar, brioche bun
US$18.00
Lost Cowboy Burger
ground angus, pepperjack, bacon, red onion, bbq sauce, mayo, matchstick potatoes, brioche bun
US$20.00
Hangover Burger
ground angus,cheddar, bacon, caramelized onion, fried egg, spicy mustard, mayo, brioche bun
US$22.00
Burger Special
US$19.00
Food - Kids
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Tenders, Shoestring Fries, House Ranch
US$8.00
Fruit & Vege Bowl
Fresh Fruit & Veges, House Ranch
US$8.00
Kids Pasta
Marinara, Parmesan
US$6.00
Food - Sauces, Sides
Bread - Croustini
US$1.00
Bread - Extra Croustini
US$0.50
Bread - Extra Toasted
US$0.50
Bread - Toasted
US$1.00
Extra Vege
US$1.00
Side 1000 Island
US$0.50
Side Balsamic Reduction
US$0.50
Side BBQ Sauce
US$0.50
Side Blue Cheese Dressing
US$0.50
Side Brandy Peppercorn Cream Sauce
US$5.00
Side Chipotle Aioli
US$0.50
Side Citrus Viniagrette
US$0.50
Side Garlic Aioli
US$0.50
Side Ginger Miso Mayo
US$0.50
Side House Hot Sauce
US$0.50
Side Jerk Sauce
US$0.50
Side Marinara
US$0.50
Side Mayo
US$0.50
Side Mustard
US$0.50
Side Mustard Sauce
US$0.50
Side Olive Oil
US$0.50
Side Orange Beet Vin.
US$0.50
Side Parmesan
US$0.50
Side Ranch
US$0.50
Side Sage Onion Gravy
US$4.00
Side Soy & Honey Sauce
US$0.50
Side Sweet Chili Sauce
US$0.50
Side Tartar
US$0.50
Side Tomato Relish
US$1.00
Beverage - Beverages
1L Sparkling Water
US$5.50
20oz Barq's Root Beer
US$4.00
20oz Coke Bottle
US$4.00
20oz Coke Zero Bottle
US$4.00
20oz Dasani Water
US$2.50
Lemonade
US$4.00
Arnold Palmer
US$3.50
Ginger Beer
US$4.00
Red Bull
US$5.00
Sugar Free Red Bull
US$5.00
Tonic Water
US$3.50
Located in the heart of Key West, Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden Menu brings a laid-back vibe with a fantastic variety of food and drinks. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pub bite or something more unique, this menu has something for everyone. Enjoy a refreshing craft beer on the outdoor patio, surrounded by the warm Key West atmosphere. From mouth-watering burgers to fresh seafood, each dish is crafted with care and bursting with flavor. You’ll find a great mix of comfort food, local favorites, and inventive twists, all served up in generous portions. With friendly service and a lively setting, the menu at Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden promises an unforgettable dining experience every time you visit.